Al Rawiya

Judge’s Dismissal Casts Further Doubt on Port Investigation Legitimacy

Six months have passed since one of the biggest non-nuclear explosions in the modern era ravaged our beloved Beirut. As today’s Lebanon continues to combat health, economic and social crises, receiving closure where we can would be more welcome than ever.

Six months have passed, and we would like nothing better than to recover, get back on our feet and move on. However, as strands of hope are getting harder to cling to, moving forward will be effectively impossible before justice is served.

Justice is owed to the excess of 200 people who were killed and the thousands who were injured or lost loved ones. It is also long overdue for the hundreds of thousands who lost their homes and businesses, and our readers, who were physically unharmed but emotionally and mentally scathed.

Every time we pass by the Port, every time we come across a windowless building and every time we hear the sound of broken glass, one critical question crosses our collective minds:

Who will be held accountable for the Beirut Explosion?

Unfortunately, after this long stretch of time, the local “investigation” has failed to yield any credible results. This can easily be attributed to political interference coupled with endemic failures of the Lebanese judicial system. In fact, given the culture of impunity and pressure from prominent groups, chances of a credible and impartial local investigation playing out are slim. To that effect, families of victims and advocacy groups like Human Rights Watch (HRW) and Amnesty International have justifiably called for an international investigation into the Port Explosion.

Since the blast, nearly 30 people, most of them Port and Customs officials, have been arrested. In December 2020, Judge Sawan filed charges against caretaker Prime Minister Hassan Diab and three other former ministers, accusing them of negligence leading to the deaths of hundreds of people. They collectively failed to appear for questioning following the charges. The summoning sparked concerted criticism from most of Lebanon’s top politicians, describing it as politically motivated.

On February 18th, 2021, after weeks of delays, the Court of Cassation asked Judge Sawan to step down. This sudden move was seemingly related to the complaints submitted by Ali Hassan Khalil and Ghazi Zeaiter. Per lawyer Diane Assaf (@lawwithdiane), the former ministers asked the judge to recuse himself, citing violations of legal and constitutional procedures. Recently, political pressure mounted when ex-minister Fenianos once again refused to comply with court summons. However, it is evident that the issuance of judicial appeals related to three Syrian businessmen with suspected ties to the port shipment sealed Sawan’s fate.

Relatives of victims of the port explosion immediately took to the streets following news of Sawan’s dismissal. They voiced the frustrations of an entire nation as the promise of accountability remains out of reach. HRW researcher Aya Majzoub described the local case as a “charade”.

Who will take over for Judge Sawan? Will the successor take the recent revelations presented by journalist Hatoum into consideration? Will they follow the trail of breadcrumbs between the explosion and the three influential businessmen tied to Syrian President Bashar al-Assad? Will the judge liaise with Interpol in relation to the red notices of the three figures? Will the local investigation uncover the truth; identifying the real criminals who destroyed our capital Beirut, and us?

Despite growing concerns over its legitimacy, the local investigation must trudge on. We’ll be following new developments intently.

The Lawyard
+ posts

The Lawyard is one of Lebanon's leading Instagram pages covering national and international news around the clock, with a special focus on political and legal analysis. From 4K to 34K followers in a year, they earned people's trust and extended their work to open the section TheLawyardCares. They decided to use their broad platform to secure donations for tuitions and housing bills to those who could not afford them. They have also provided medications, medical beds and oxygen machines, during the Covid-19 healthcare crisis. The Lawyard is currently run by two young, brilliant and passionate female founders willing to spread knowledge and tackle the truth.

Related

Our Latest Posts

Terror_Sakina-Mokaddem-675x450
ART
Rasha Hamade: Two Years With Grief
2_6
Can Lebanon’s Winds of Change Extend to Prison Reform?: A Discussion with "Second Wind" Directors Nessim Stevenson and Tariq Keblaoui
Foreword:In a fabric of collapsing infrastructures, the daily challenges endured by former prison inmates...
Thousands of protesters took over the streets during the October Revolution. October 2019, Beirut, Lebanon
The (Up)rising of Political Freedom
  As I was walking down the streets in the middle of the crowd on October 17, 2019, I felt extremely...
AprotestercarriesaplacardthatreadsAugust4AJusticeDayforLebanonduringthefirstcommemorationoftheBeirutPortExplosiononAugust42021.PhotobySelimBitaronshutterstock
August 4th Investigation: Challenging a Regime Rife with Impunity
Credits: A protester carries a placard that reads “August 4, A Justice Day for Lebanon”,...
Pic-3
Lebanon’s Prosecutorial Authority, a Shield for Protecting Society or an Arm of the Political System?
Credits: Judge Ghada Aoun talking to reporters after storming the Mecattaf Holding Group’s offices –...